| Platinum | Alerus Center |
| Gold | BJ Armani |
| Silver | Wild and Untamed Things (Rocky Horror) |
| Bronze | Shelby Frank |
| Top Pick | Empire Arts Center |
| Top Pick | Forx Roller Derby |
| Top Pick | Nine and Numb Improv |
| Top Pick | Owl |
| Top Pick | River Cities Speedway |
| Top Pick | Your Alibi |