| Platinum | Bernie's |
| Gold | Moehrings Homemade |
| Silver | Real Good Cookies |
| Bronze | O For Heaven's Cakes N' More |
| Top Pick | Cookies By Erin |
| Top Pick | Crumbl Cookie |
| Top Pick | Farm Fresh Cookies |
| Top Pick | Insomnia Cookies |
| Top Pick | Kelly's Flour Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Perkins Restaurant & Bakery |