| Platinum | Charras and Tequila |
| Gold | Casa Mexico of East Grand Forks |
| Silver | Chicago Burritos |
| Bronze | Melissa's Mobile Cocina |
| Top Pick | El Gordito |
| Top Pick | Mexican Village |
| Top Pick | Paradiso Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | QDOBA Mexican Eats |
| Top Pick | Sadie Lewis |