| Platinum | Panera Bread |
| Gold | Dhi Sweet Street |
| Silver | Bernie's |
| Bronze | Hugo's Family Marketplace |
| Top Pick | Fifi's Sugar Rush |
| Top Pick | Little Birds Breadery |
| Top Pick | Moehrings Homemade |
| Top Pick | Perkins Restaurant & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Something Sweet Bakery & Catering |